Our Blog

After a car accident, injured victims are often focused on medical treatment, getting their vehicles fixed, and the day-to-day details of recovering after a car crash. If you do file an insurance claim against the at-fault driver, you may not realize that another issue may arise. If you receive compensation through a settlement or verdict at trial, an insurance company may later seek repayment for benefits it already paid on your behalf.

The legal doctrine of subrogation allows insurance companies to seek reimbursement from accident victims. While there are some protections for South Carolina accident victims, subrogation can significantly affect how much money you ultimately keep after resolving a car accident claim. Our Simpsonville car accident lawyers will fight to help you get maximum compensation for your losses.

At Brooks Derrick Accident and Injury Lawyers, we have deep experience in handling car accident claims, including dealing with subrogation and liens. We use our skills and knowledge to help our clients get the best possible outcome for their case. Contact our law firm today to schedule a free consultation with a Simpsonville personal injury attorney.

What Is Subrogation?

Subrogation is a legal process that allows an insurance company (or another party) that paid benefits to an injured person to seek reimbursement. This reimbursement may come from the at-fault party or the injured person’s settlement.

In simple terms, subrogation prevents an injured person from receiving a “double recovery” for the same damages. It also prevents a person from getting paid for expenses that were covered by another party. 

For example, your health insurance company pays $20,000 in medical bills after a South Carolina car accident. You later recover $100,000 in compensation from the at-fault driver, which includes money for these medical expenses. Your health insurance company may seek repayment through subrogation for some or all of those medical expenses.

Subrogation commonly arises in:

• Car accident claims
• Health insurance cases
• Workers’ compensation claims
• Uninsured or underinsured motorist cases
• Medical payments coverage (MedPay) claims

While subrogation is common in South Carolina car accident cases, it isn’t always automatic or unlimited. South Carolina law and the terms of the insurance policy often determine whether reimbursement is permitted and how much can be recovered. Our Simpsonville car accident attorneys can help you understand your rights when it comes to subrogation and your claim.

How Subrogation Works in a South Carolina Car Accident Claim

The subrogation process typically follows several steps.

1. An Insurance Company Pays Benefits. After a crash, your own insurance company or health insurer may pay for:
   • Medical treatment
   • Hospital bills
   • Prescription medications
   • Physical therapy
   • Vehicle repairs
   • Rental car expenses

This can occur long before your personal injury case is resolved.

2. You Pursue a Claim Against the At-Fault Driver. You may file an insurance claim or personal injury lawsuit against the at-fault driver to seek compensation for:
   • Medical expenses
   • Lost wages
   • Pain and suffering
   • Property damage
   • Future medical care

3. The Insurance Company Asserts a Subrogation Claim. Once the insurer learns you may receive compensation, it may notify you or your attorney that it intends to seek reimbursement from your settlement proceeds. The insurer may place a lien against your recovery or demand repayment after the case settles.

4. Negotiation Often Occurs. Subrogation claims are frequently negotiable. An experienced South Carolina personal injury attorney may be able to reduce the amount owed, especially if:
   • Liability is disputed.
   • The settlement is limited.
   • The injured person was not fully compensated.
   • Attorney’s fees reduced the net recovery.

South Carolina’s Made Whole and Common Fund Doctrines

One important protection for injury victims in South Carolina is the “made whole” doctrine. Under this legal principle, an insurance company generally cannot enforce subrogation rights unless the injured person has been fully compensated for their losses. Under South Carolina law, a party claiming subrogation rights must establish that “no injustice will be done to the other party by the allowance of the equity.”

This doctrine recognizes that accident victims should be prioritized before insurers recover reimbursement. For example, consider a situation where you are hurt in a car accident and:

• Your total damages equal $200,000.
• The at-fault driver only has $50,000 in insurance coverage.
• Your health insurer paid $25,000 in medical expenses.

If you settle your claim for the available $50,000 policy limits, you clearly have not been fully compensated for your losses. In some situations, the “made whole” doctrine may limit or prevent the insurer’s reimbursement claim.

South Carolina also recognizes the “common fund” doctrine, which may reduce the amount that an insurance company can recover through subrogation. Under this doctrine, if your attorney’s efforts created the settlement fund from which the insurer seeks reimbursement, the insurer may be required to share in the attorney’s fees and litigation costs.

For example, your attorney secures a $100,000 settlement in a case where your health insurance company is seeking reimbursement of $20,000 in medical expenses. Your attorney’s fee is ⅓ of your recovery. In this case, the insurance company’s recovery may be reduced proportionally because it benefited from your lawyer’s work.

These doctrines can be complicated and technical and may not apply in all cases. However, both can be important negotiating tools in personal injury cases. If you have any questions about how these doctrines may affect subrogation in your case, our Simpsonville car accident lawyers can help you understand your rights.

Can Subrogation Affect My Car Accident Settlement?

In a car accident claim, subrogation can substantially reduce the amount of compensation that you actually receive. Many accident victims focus only on the gross settlement amount without realizing that outstanding liens and reimbursement claims may need to be resolved before funds are distributed.

Potential deductions may include:

• Health insurance reimbursement
• Medicare or Medicaid liens
• Workers’ compensation liens
• Attorney’s fees
• Case expenses

Because of this, evaluating a settlement offer requires looking at the net recovery, not just the headline number. Our attorneys can help you understand these deductions and how they impact your settlement.

How a South Carolina Car Accident Lawyer Can Help

Subrogation claims can be complex. For example, insurance companies sometimes assert reimbursement claims that are excessive, unsupported, or unenforceable.  These types of claims can also become complicated when multiple parties assert competing reimbursement claims.

Without careful legal analysis, an accident victim could inadvertently:

• Accept an invalid or excessive subrogation claim
• Settle too early
• Accept too little compensation
• Violate lien obligations
• Face collection efforts after a settlement

Handling subrogation properly is an important part of maximizing compensation after a car accident. A Simpsonville car accident attorney can help by:

1. Identifying All Potential Claims: A lawyer can determine which parties may assert reimbursement rights early in the case.
2. Verifying the Amount Claimed: Insurance companies sometimes include unrelated charges, duplicate bills, or inflated amounts in their demands.
3. Negotiating Reductions: Many subrogation claims are negotiable. To reduce repayment obligations, attorneys may use:
   • The made whole doctrine 
   • The common fund doctrine
   • Liability disputes
   • Policy limits issues
   • Hardship considerations

4. Protecting the Settlement Process: Improperly resolving subrogation claims can delay settlement distribution or create future legal exposure. An attorney helps ensure claims are handled correctly before funds are disbursed.
5. Maximizing Net Compensation: Ultimately, the goal is not simply obtaining a large settlement, but maximizing the amount that you actually keep as the injury victim.

Contact a Simpsonville Car Accident Attorney for a Free Consultation

Subrogation is one of the most overlooked aspects of a South Carolina car accident claim, but it can have a major impact on your financial recovery. Insurance companies, healthcare providers, and government benefit programs may all attempt to recover money from your settlement after paying accident-related expenses. Working with an experienced South Carolina personal injury lawyer can help ensure that reimbursement claims are properly evaluated, negotiated, and resolved so you can pursue maximum compensation.

Brooks Derrick Accident and Injury Lawyers handles all aspects of motor vehicle accident cases, including subrogation issues. We work hard to help our clients get the highest possible recovery for their losses. Call our law offices at 864-531-7765 or fill out our online contact form to schedule a free consultation with a Simpsonville car accident lawyer.